that would match his previous non violent MO nature …. LOL


“44 prior arrests, One of which he ouches an elderly woman in the face breaking bones which he did no time for and then he did FOUR months for trying to kidnap a four year old girl. The city/state failed him and the citizens of the city and state.”

The marine should sue the state.

DQ I pray for wisdom every day. Would you do it just once?

He also assaulted a man

"Filemon Castillo Baltazar told the New York Daily News that he was waiting for a train in the Greenwich Village in 2019 when Neely approached him out of nowhere and punched him in the head, eventually leading Neely to be charged with assault in a case that has since been sealed. "

https://www.thedailybeast.com/assault-victim-says-he-wishes-jordan-neely-had-been-in-rehab

Detectives investigated and chose not to arrest him. The DA’s office circumvented the process and issued a warrant before a grand jury’s decision. That’s what I have issue with.

even I couldn't find a way to argue with that

I’m think some of you are equating the background of the dead guy to being justified. This should be looked at through the lens of both people having the same value to society.

If it was your own choir boy son, would you feel the same?

He was a real fine upstanding member of society

One thing is certain, if he wouldn't had been on that train acting a fool/running his mouth he would still be here today.

It's insane that anybody would think a Marine who served his country who has a clean record would have the same value to society as a deadbeat who's been arrested 44 times.

The family's faux outrage is pretty laughable.

Where we they at? Why was their son homeless? Why didn't they help him? Now that he is dead all of the sudden they're rallying around him.. Seems kind of self-serving to me, almost like they want their 15 minutes or they think they're going to get paid.

They keep blaming it on the city or the government or the marine. Where is the blame for the idiot that put himself in this situation?

If a cow had balls she’d be a bull. But she don’t.

you are better than me

No relevance, no relevance to the actions of that day as has been said by pretty every legal expert to date. None of those riders that day were part or privy to any prior arrests, tickets, etc. That point has been made ad nauseum. Making noise about it changes nothing in the events on that train, that day. And has also been said, 40 of those arrests related to petty train trespass or failure to pay for access.

NY DA let’s people sell drugs, shoot people, carjack and terrorize every day. Wants no bail. Majority of his felony cases are downgraded to misdemeanor.

What makes this the case the case to spare no cost to the DA? Request bail? A guy with zero criminal history.

That would be too compassionate or logical of a way of thinking for this crew..Sad to say.

Lol you know the answer to that.

Negative

I'm sure the deadbeat bum had plenty of compassion when he was breaking bones in that elderly womans face.
Some of you are so soft it's embarrassing to everyone

I’ve recently dealt with something real close to home. Where someone’s past was totally irrelevant because it happened when they were a minor. So instead of going to prison for up to 20 they went for 18 month. Someone that is a threat to society and women. I hope that when they get out in September that it’s not your family they come after next time. But I pray more that it’s not mine again.

So take your compassion somewhere else where a grandmothers face wasn’t broken and a 4 year old wasn’t kidnapped.

I concur on the last statement! Green to you Sir!

Compassion for lowlife losers like this one is partly why we are here. I’ll take your comment as a compliment.

its called a proven propensity for illegal and unprovoked violence toward others.

what was your MOS in the army, Im genuinely curious why you take such a budist approach in every one of these self defense conversations.

91-Bravo!

work on the must frustrating over used and abused equipment owned by the US and you are a pacifist. Go figure

Floyd was suffocated also

Not Budhist approach, more of a humanistic perspective of life where all lives are precious and irreplaceable. The day I stop thinking that way will be the day I go 6' under.