Looks like the same one to me, but if it is, there is very little difference between last year and this year that I can tell.
(The ones that are dated 2009 are actually pics taken in 2010.)

Probably not but it could be.

Looks like the same deer to me, but his body doesn't look as big as last year. Guess he hasn't been eating much.

X2 i believe the pic from this year is of a 3 year old and the pic from last year is of a 3 now 4 year old. Unless at stated above he didn't eat much cause his belly was def. bigger last year. I think they def. have the same dad though.

I called them both 3 year olds, but they sure look alike. This stand usually has 5-7 ten pointers a year at it, so it very easily could be different deer. They just seem an awful lot alike and our deer aren't doing just great this year. I posted another series of a buck from last year to this year, and the difference was obvious.

Are the dates right?3

I see the bottom two as being the same deer and the top one I think is a didfferent deer. If one and 2 are from the same year, I think 2 has too much curve in the G-3 on the right side to be the buck in pic one. His G-4 also looks longer.

matt

The dates are right, but the year is off on the top two. The bottom one is this year and the top two are from last year.

Looking at it now, the top two are different deer. Like I said in the previous post, there are alot of tens at this stand. Most the ones that I had last year had kickers so it was easy to tell the difference...guess I mixed those two up because of no kicker

Waffling on your own post now

The 2nd pic and 3rd pic buck looks to be the same but he went down a bunch if it is the same. Really hard to tell from just those 2 pics though.

Same deer. He's wider this year with lessened tine length.

If he's not the same deer, the 2 have remarkably similar characteristics showing up in the same order.

The white patch just behind the nose does look different in the bottom 2 versus the top. Might just be the pictures.

Pretty sure I have a few more that I can post tomorrow. Problem is that there always seems to be alot of 3.5 year old tens that come to this stand and few make it back at 4.5. Across that fence is 3500 acres of unhunted land, so hard to believe they get shot. Only thing I can think I they get pushed to another area by a more dominant buck.


and yes...if I have ever waffled before, this was probably one that my first guess wasn't even close.