Texas Hunting Forum

.270 or .308?

Posted By: wigeon

.270 or .308? - 02/06/10 12:15 AM

I am getting another rifle to compliment my .243 Most of my shots will be under 250 yards for deer and hogs.Eventually I will use it for elk and bigger bodied deer. I have looked at the ballistics of both and seen that they are extremely close to about 300 yards.
I was wanting to know what do ya'll think I should get?

Posted By: txhunter24

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 12:22 AM

.308 IMO. Im the proud owner of a .270 but .308's are great.

Posted By: txtrophy85

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 12:24 AM

six in one hand/half dozen in the other...


both are good, i shoot an .270, but i've had hunters use a .308 very succesfully.

i just like the .270 cause its a tad faster out of the gate, but in real world no difference whatsoever.

both will perform on elk as well

Posted By: pig out

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 01:17 AM

i have a .270 and love it!! it's my favorite rifle i own!! i have just hunted deer and hogs with it though. good luck in finding a good rifle.

Posted By: Mr. 2 Million

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 01:32 AM

I like the 308 basically a larger necked 243 so the recoil and all are about the same , just have to be careful because the rounds do look a lot alike in low light

Posted By: luv2brode

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 02:09 AM

i like the 308 but the 270 is an outstanding round

Posted By: Grizz

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 02:39 AM

Originally Posted By: luv2brode
i like the 308 but the 270 is an outstanding round


My sentiments exactly. I prefer the 308, but you can't go wrong with either.

Posted By: David Morris

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 04:00 AM

I would advise you to look at a .270 WSM. That is what I am currently using for South Texas whitetail, amoung other various North American game. It is more accurate, shoots flatter, and has more kinetic energy than both the .270 and .308. It is just an all-around "BEAST" of a caliber. But if you only want to consider a .270 or .308, I would advise the .308.

Posted By: notamtchance

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 04:16 AM

308 for longer shots and bigger animals. The 308 is a more consistent accurate round that is why the majority of competion shotters use the 308 rounds.

Posted By: Driller

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 04:22 AM

Both are great and fairly equal. I would avoid the WSMs as ammo is harder to find and more expensive and it will only get worse as time passes.

Posted By: Halfadozen

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 04:33 AM

.270 all the way

Posted By: TEXASLEFTY

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 01:38 PM

Originally Posted By: notamtchance
308 for longer shots and bigger animals. The 308 is a more consistent accurate round that is why the majority of competion shotters use the 308 rounds.


LMAO!!! thats just all I can say, I do not think any part of this quote is accurate or honest.

They both are great rounds, the .308 is a short action and can be more accurate at super long ranges. The .270 is long action and is flatter IMO at certian ranges, like the typical longer shots on an elk. Get what you like however if you chamber a .243 in a .308 it will blow up the case and could damage the throat of your brand new .308.

Posted By: powerstroke

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 01:44 PM

NEVER NEEDED ANYTHING OTHER THAN THE 270

Posted By: Texpppr

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 02:11 PM

I like the .308.. Shoots heavier bullets

Posted By: 30378

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 02:34 PM

The 308 gets my vote. Heavier bullets and better choice of projectiles.

Posted By: hwillliams88

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 02:51 PM

Like someone previously stated take a look at the 270wsm love mine. As far as ammo never had a problem finding silvertips and federal tsx's and prices have dropped about $10 for each box over the last 2 years I can get a box of silvertips for 39.99 and tsx's for 51.00

Posted By: txbigly

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 04:03 PM

One more for the .270

Posted By: Texas Whitetail Hunter

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 05:49 PM

another vote for the .270

Posted By: rifleman

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 06:02 PM

270 shooting old school 130gr silver tips... or a 270wsm reloaded hot w/ 140gr accubonds. Doubt I will ever own another 308.

Posted By: Oline Coach

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 06:05 PM

I own 270 and hunt more often with 264 win. mag but 308 is larger and in some cased more accurate. As someone said either or!!

Posted By: sig226fan (Rguns.com)

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 06:17 PM

Both are fine, I have both, and never shoot the 270

Posted By: jlbarker

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/06/10 11:12 PM

308 is sweet!

Posted By: ctonsmitty

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 02:58 AM

IMO, flip a coin for the .270 or .308. As far as the .243, I have probably lost 5 or so deer in my lifetime with it and the people I hunt with lost some deer last year with the .243 and .22-250. Guess what....we all shot .270 this year and did not lose any deer this season. What does that tell ya?

Posted By: TreeBass

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 03:17 AM

love the .308

Posted By: notamtchance

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 04:08 AM

Originally Posted By: TEXASLEFTY
Originally Posted By: notamtchance
308 for longer shots and bigger animals. The 308 is a more consistent accurate round that is why the majority of competion shotters use the 308 rounds.


LMAO!!! thats just all I can say, I do not think any part of this quote is accurate or honest.

They both are great rounds, the .308 is a short action and can be more accurate at super long ranges. The .270 is long action and is flatter IMO at certian ranges, like the typical longer shots on an elk. Get what you like however if you chamber a .243 in a .308 it will blow up the case and could damage the throat of your brand new .308.



Don't take my word for it. Do the research yourself. I have several friends how do compition shooting all the time and all of them use custom 308. I personly like a 270, but I do not shoot 300 to 600 yrd shots while hunting, nor hunt big game. Deer is the bigest I've hunted.

Posted By: poisonivie

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 04:18 AM

Originally Posted By: ctonsmitty
IMO, flip a coin for the .270 or .308. As far as the .243, I have probably lost 5 or so deer in my lifetime with it and the people I hunt with lost some deer last year with the .243 and .22-250. Guess what....we all shot .270 this year and did not lose any deer this season. What does that tell ya?


That y'all practiced more? grin

Posted By: bigdavehunting

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 04:54 AM

I will help you make your decision, I have a extra 270 I will sell you. It is a remington ADL synthetic has had a trigger job and a floated barrel shots well. I'm looking to get a sendero in a 270 for my brother. It has a leupold vx 11 3-9x50. Can go with it, or without it. with 625 without 425. gun and scope are in good shape.

Posted By: michael rice

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 04:56 AM

270

Posted By: 280AI

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 05:29 AM

.280

Posted By: TEXASLEFTY

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 06:27 AM

Originally Posted By: notamtchance
Originally Posted By: TEXASLEFTY
Originally Posted By: notamtchance
308 for longer shots and bigger animals. The 308 is a more consistent accurate round that is why the majority of competion shotters use the 308 rounds.


LMAO!!! thats just all I can say, I do not think any part of this quote is accurate or honest.

They both are great rounds, the .308 is a short action and can be more accurate at super long ranges. The .270 is long action and is flatter IMO at certian ranges, like the typical longer shots on an elk. Get what you like however if you chamber a .243 in a .308 it will blow up the case and could damage the throat of your brand new .308.



Don't take my word for it. Do the research yourself. I have several friends how do compition shooting all the time and all of them use custom 308. I personly like a 270, but I do not shoot 300 to 600 yrd shots while hunting, nor hunt big game. Deer is the bigest I've hunted.


snipershide.com

Posted By: Lone Ranger

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 06:53 AM

270 or better still the 270WSM!!!

Posted By: HornHunter

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 10:41 AM

Originally Posted By: DrillerJ
Both are great and fairly equal. I would avoid the WSMs as ammo is harder to find and more expensive and it will only get worse as time passes.


Agree... Try finding WSMs in a small little town...Hell their even hard to find in a big town sometimes...

The 308 gets my vote

Posted By: Txkiller

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 03:48 PM

I love the .270

Posted By: obryankl

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 03:58 PM

Originally Posted By: Txkiller
I love the .270


x2

Posted By: Texas Proud

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 05:38 PM

I like both, but would rather shoot a .270 Win over the .308. No need for heavy bullets to kill an elk either. A heavier bullet is great for shooting long range (500yds +). Since most fo your shots will be under 250yds the .270 Win is the best IMO. I'd recommend a good 130gr soft point bullet (Sierra Game King) for deer and possibly go up to 140gr (Nosler Accubond) for elk. The best grouping ammo is what I'd use all the time though. You and the rifle will need to make that decission though. Good luck and let us know what ya get.

Posted By: rifleman

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/07/10 07:33 PM

Originally Posted By: rifleman
270 shooting old school 130gr silver tips... or a 270wsm reloaded hot w/ 140gr accubonds. Doubt I will ever own another 308.


let me rephrase this..... I would like to own a Lazz 308 warbird at some point.

Posted By: sig226fan (Rguns.com)

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/08/10 02:32 PM

Originally Posted By: rifleman
Originally Posted By: rifleman
270 shooting old school 130gr silver tips... or a 270wsm reloaded hot w/ 140gr accubonds. Doubt I will ever own another 308.


let me rephrase this..... I would like to own a Lazz 308 warbird at some point.


THeres a rocket....... wow

Posted By: BOBO the Clown

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/08/10 02:52 PM

257 wby or 270.

Posted By: J45on

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/08/10 03:02 PM

are you a reloader, or are you limited to only factory loads? I'd give .308 the advantage to a reloader because of the massive variety of bullets in that caliber.

I'd give the .270 the advantage in recoil, given similar rifles. The advantage goes back to the .308 for intrinsic accuracy and the short action. But the .270 gets nostalgia points.

But another consideration is the platform. What rifles are you looking at? Is your favorite choice of rifle available in both of these calibers?

so, what is most important to YOU?

Posted By: scott1071

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/08/10 04:47 PM

There is probably a reason that a lot of snipers use 308, but I'm not a sniper and won't be dropping any deer at 800 yds so I'd flip a coin.

Posted By: wigeon

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/08/10 11:08 PM

I was looking at a Tikka or maybe a Ruger. What ever I get a good deal on. I have a Tikka in a .243 that I love so I am partial to Tikka.

I thought that a .308 would have less recoil than a .270. It is not much difference though

Posted By: DFWPI

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/08/10 11:20 PM

Originally Posted By: ctonsmitty
IMO, flip a coin for the .270 or .308. As far as the .243, I have probably lost 5 or so deer in my lifetime with it and the people I hunt with lost some deer last year with the .243 and .22-250. Guess what....we all shot .270 this year and did not lose any deer this season. What does that tell ya?


That some people don't know how to shoot or where to place the bullet?

Posted By: Big_Country01

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 12:56 AM

Originally Posted By: ctonsmitty
IMO, flip a coin for the .270 or .308. As far as the .243, I have probably lost 5 or so deer in my lifetime with it and the people I hunt with lost some deer last year with the .243 and .22-250. Guess what....we all shot .270 this year and did not lose any deer this season. What does that tell ya?


Sounds to me like poor shot placement.

I would go with the .270 IMO

Posted By: J45on

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 01:22 AM

In general, .270 cartridges have lighter bullets, decreasing recoil and .308s in general have faster powders in their shorter cases, which increases felt recoil. You're right though, it's not much difference. I should have said a 'slight' advantage to the .270; but then any advantage between these two cartridges is going to be slight.

Posted By: cameron00

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 02:03 PM

The .308 all the way.

Both are great, but as stated, nobody uses a .270 as a sniper gun. The .308 is pretty much the standard.

Posted By: cameron00

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 02:09 PM

Seriously though, this is like asking Marissa Miller or Bar Rafaeli.

Posted By: sig226fan (Rguns.com)

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 02:38 PM

Originally Posted By: cameron00
Seriously though, this is like asking Marissa Miller or Bar Rafaeli.


WHO???????? I must be getting old....... someone date this for me?

Posted By: catchin'

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 02:53 PM

Originally Posted By: HornHunter
Originally Posted By: DrillerJ
Both are great and fairly equal. I would avoid the WSMs as ammo is harder to find and more expensive and it will only get worse as time passes.


Agree... Try finding WSMs in a small little town...Hell their even hard to find in a big town sometimes...

The 308 gets my vote




My son shoots a 270 WSM and the rounds have been easier to find lately and they are making more of a variety, now. But having said that they are not as plentiful as the 270 or 308 rounds.

Posted By: Precision_Shooter

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 04:18 PM

wigeon, Where are you located? I have a Tikka T3 Lite with Leupold scope that is my Deer Gun. You are more than welcome to shoot it at the range to see if you like it.

Posted By: Payne

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 04:33 PM

Originally Posted By: sig226fan (Rguns.com)
Originally Posted By: cameron00
Seriously though, this is like asking Marissa Miller or Bar Rafaeli.


WHO???????? I must be getting old....... someone date this for me?



Marisa Miller




Bar Rafaeli



Posted By: Payne

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 04:35 PM

Oh yeah back on topic, 270.

Posted By: sig226fan (Rguns.com)

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 05:34 PM

OK, so that's like arguing Shania or Faith, I got it.... Shania btw...

Posted By: wigeon

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 08:38 PM

Originally Posted By: Precision_Shooter
wigeon, Where are you located? I have a Tikka T3 Lite with Leupold scope that is my Deer Gun. You are more than welcome to shoot it at the range to see if you like it.


Sounds good man, Im in Fort Worth. When I go shoot I got to alpine

Posted By: Buckbuster

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 09:58 PM

i couldnt make up my mind which round I liked best either...so got both!

Posted By: Justin T

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/09/10 10:01 PM

Originally Posted By: Buckbuster
i couldnt make up my mind which round I liked best either...so got both!


Are we still talking about bullets?

Posted By: Mr. Clean

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/14/10 03:47 PM

Originally Posted By: Payne
Originally Posted By: sig226fan (Rguns.com)
Originally Posted By: cameron00
Seriously though, this is like asking Marissa Miller or Bar Rafaeli.


WHO???????? I must be getting old....... someone date this for me?



Marisa Miller





Bar Rafaeli





Ummmm.....I like 'em both.

Oh yea, I prefer the 308 over the 270 but it's ultimately up to the shooter??!!


Posted By: Texas Proud

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/14/10 04:13 PM

Well, did ya decide yet? Caliber or the girls? bolt

Posted By: jds15151

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/14/10 04:24 PM

.308 and Bar

Posted By: sig226fan (Rguns.com)

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/14/10 05:17 PM

308 and there are better girls out there

Posted By: wigeon

Re: .270 or .308? - 02/14/10 05:31 PM

yup, ive decided to get the 308. love short actions and the larger bullet.

© 2024 Texas Hunting Forum